Normally, this time of night I would sit down and start to code, or maybe play a game, or catch an episode of Fringe streamed off my PS3. But tonight, after a great baseball practice I felt the need to share one of my favorite all time baseball stories.
The Beginning
I guess it all started about 18 months ago, in the fall of 2008. We got together with some friends and decided to put together a winter baseball team. All our boys were moving from Farm to Minors – from machine pitch to kid pitch and I knew two things. First, kids that played some winter ball and then went into little league were a lot better prepared than kids that only started up a month before the season began. Second, I knew that the jump to kid pitch was a big jump. I lied, there was a third thing I knew. On my farm team were 4 or 5 kids who didn’t get drafted into the minors. Getting drafted was tough.
Early Goals

So we pulled together some friends and we said, “hey look, we all want to play minors next year and there’s no guarantee any of them will get drafted.” So we figured if we put together a team for winter ball, played up against better competition and focused on pitching, we could:
- Teach the kids how to pitch
- Get them ready for showcase improving their chances of getting drafted
- Get them ready to face live kid pitching
What I also had in mind is that I wanted to learn how to teach pitching. I often saw a lot of kids that wanted to pitch, but no one knew how to teach them. I figured if everyone bought into the idea that our focus was to teach pitching and get drafted, who cared if we won any games or not? That was a good idea, because it turns out we only won a single game – but all the kids improved. They all learned to pitch. And most importantly, every single one got drafted into minors.
Now The Fun Begins

The one drag about playing in Tempe South minors was that we did draft. I couldn’t just pick my whole team. I could only get a few of the players that I’d invested months in teaching. Sometimes that was a good thing. Some kids just need a change of scenery and I’d helped them as much as I could. With other kids it was hard for me, the kid, and parents. We wanted to play together, to keep going but I just couldn’t pick everyone. However, this I didn’t expect. It was awesome knowing someone on every team in the league. We had friends everywhere. So my team, my Red Sox, started practicing, and drilling, and learning and my God was it fun. I love teaching baseball.
This was my first year managing in the minors, so I was a little nervous. I was going up against legendary local coaches like Griffin Merkel, John Briscoe and Mark McGinnis. Virtually everyone in the league had coached and managed more than I had. I was lucky to be selected as a manager. Some of these guys managed a real club team, a team that had gone 17-0 in fall baseball. What did I know? But I gave it my all and most importantly so did my beloved Red Sox.
Scrimmage

After three weeks of practice, we scrimmaged the Cubs. We had a plan. I was ready. The boys were ready. We got shelled. It was a humbling experience, but like winter ball, we weren’t really playing to win. We were playing to learn specific things about our team. Who could pitch, who could play here, and who could catch? And after that, we spent two practices covering lessons we learned during the game.
The Season
Finally it was time for the season. And here’s my real story. Surprisingly, we came out of the gate and won our first game. It was a close contest, but we prevailed. Putting our players in positions of strength they did really, really well and it was fun. Then we won our second game. It was a little less of a nail biter, but we pulled it out. After the third win, it started to feel like something special. I remember our third contest. We faced Jay Bauerle’s Indians. It was a close game. We lead the whole time. But when my starter began to get tired, the Indians came roaring back. They pulled within one run in the bottom of the sixth. And we put in Bandit. (One thing you should know about my teams. I always give the kids nicknames). With the tying run on third and two outs, Bandit struck out the last batter to seal the win. My best friend and assistant Coach Ed looks at me says, “I think we found our closer.”

Suddenly, it felt like this was a special team with a special group of kids. We were undefeated. But we weren’t the only ones. The Astros – coached by Kevin Costigan and John Bistany, were right there matching us win for win. And suddenly Astros V Red Sox started to look like a showdown. And it was. The Astros were a great team. And yet, we prevailed. We started the season 7-0. We eventually went on to finish in first place with a record of 10-1-3. Three Ties! We were a tough team to beat.
RedSox at Diamondbacks Day 2009
The best part of the entire season was that the kids really liked each other. They liked hanging out together, they liked going to D-Backs games together. The loved playing baseball together. I really enjoyed managing them. It was the highlight of my week.
The Playoffs
We were heavily favored to win. But this is little league. Suddenly those teams that seemed so easy to beat in the begging of the season were hitting and fielding. Easy ground balls in game 3 that lead to hits and runs were suddenly outs. Three of the first four minors playoff games were decided by 2 runs or less. Tempe South has something special. We play at a local field where all 4 diamonds back up together – and it feels like the whole community comes out to watch. Two elementary schools in particular feed our league and on Saturday nights all the minors and majors play – it seems like the whole neighborhood turns out to watch. People will walk, or ride their bikes down to the ball park to see 150 kids play baseball for two hours. There’s nothing quite like it. And as you can imagine, at playoff time, we really draw a crowd.
Losing
While we won our first game, it was a our second that tripped us up. Heavily favored to win the entire tournament we didn’t expect to get into a dog fight. Nor did we expect to drop our second playoff game by a score of 4-3. Four to Three! In a league where scoring 13 runs was common.
I remember being personally devastated. I remember feeling the tension rise as the kids went from discussing what they would do after they won, to realizing the game was slipping away from them. My best hitters started to press. They were swinging at garbage. I had two kids who’d hit 700 all year long – seriously, 3 out of 4 times they came to the plate they hit – both strike out back to back with the tying run on third. We had two excellent chances to tie the game but just couldn’t get the runner home from third. We were shell shocked. All of us.
The Believe Rock
Ed and I didn’t know what to do. Then Ed’s wife Beth suggested Ed loan me their “believe rock”. It was a simple rock, a souvenir, from the Boston Red Sox 2004 World Series win. As the story goes, the Sox had made a similar rock with the word believe on it. And the luck of the rock had helped them win the series. Ed was a little embarrassed to tell me about it. To him it sounded kind of hokey, but something about it struck me just right. We needed to get our minds off the loss and move forward. We needed to get our swagger back – to shift our thinking and the rock seemed like just the thing.
So at the next game – we got to the field early, and because it was hotter than sin out in late May, we all put ice towels on our heads, and we stood in a circle around home plate. I held the stone out and said, “I am Coach Scott, and I believe today everyone will do their best. And win or lose, the Red Sox will play their best game ever. I then passed the stone to the player on my right. Then in sequence the stone made its way around the circle, each and every player stated their name and something positive they believed about the team. Finally the stone reached Ed who said my favorite thing. He said simply, “My name is Coach Ed, and I believe in the Red Sox, and I believe in each one of you.” Then we all came into the middle, put our hands on the stone and chanted, “I believe.”
Beware the Man Who Has Hope
I was going to say that I don’t know if it was the stone or not, but that would be a lie. It was the stone. Granted, the rock can’t play second base, or swing a bat, but it did focus us. It did bring us together. The ritual of sharing our hopes and dreams I believe was a powerful thing and it showed up that day against the Cubs. We found ourselves in the losers bracket, and if we wanted to win a championship we would have to climb up the losers ladder and beat the team from the winning bracket twice. Not only that, but the way the days fell we would have to be very careful and very lucky with our pitching. Little league has strict pitch counts and if players throw too many pitches in one game they are ineligible for the next. Winners get more days to rest. We definitely didn’t take the easy road.
I found out later, that one of the cubs players not knowing who they would play that day, ran up to the field and when they saw our banner shouted, “Oh Crap, it’s the Red Sox!” We won in convincing fashion 13-6. Our boys came out swinging from the first pitch and kept it up to the last. Near the end of the game, I remember looking at Showtime (our best player) and telling him, “You have 14 pitches to end this game.” The meaning was clear. If we went over 14 pitches we would be unable to use him in the next game. He threw only 13. And ended the game with a diving catch near third. The Red Sox definitely believed.
On a Mission
For our next game it was the same. We’d show up early, perform our pregame ritual of sharing our beliefs about the game and each other, and then we would go play. Win or lose, I believed everyone would do their best. Again, we scored 14 runs and gave up less than 10. We stayed alive to play another day. We joked we were playing Maximum Baseball. If we won it all we would play 7 games. The regular season was only 14. We’d play another half season – if we could get there.
And finally, we faced our nemesis, the team that had knocked us into the losers bracket – and that was the most intense hard fought game I can ever remember playing in. But we prevailed. Both teams played an excellent game, but in the end, we were able to pull it out. We were going to the championship against the A’s. We had made it.
A Championship to Remember

The first game of the championship was quite dully actually. We had all our pitchers so we threw our ace. Big Sarge. He threw a complete game and The Red Sox won in dominating fashion. However… the rain started to fall. A second game would have to be postponed. 6 days later – Game 2 of the Minors championship was on.
It didn’t start well for the Red Sox. The A’s threw their crafty left handed pitcher and our batters hungry for hits just couldn’t hold back. We played a strategy where our B-Pitchers would start the game (hopefully chewing up innings) so that we could finish with our Ace. That strategy didn’t work out quite like we planned. We were the visiting team and after 2 innings we found ourselves down 7 to 0. That was hard, but… our catcher – we called him Mad Dog – caught a runner missing home plate when he ‘scored’ a run. The player ran up to the plate but never touched it and went into the dug out. Mad Dog turned to the Umpire and said, “he missed the plate.” The ump said, “I can’t help you but your coach can.” Mad Dog came to me and I told him what to do. “Go stand on home plate. Throw the pitcher the ball. Now have the pitcher throw you the ball. Step on the plate. Now look a the umpire.” (this is called an appeal) The ump called the runner out. I couldn’t believe it. Our stands erupted in cheers and so did our boys. It was a silly play – the other side just didn’t realize he’d missed home. But we needed the lift and at the start of the next inning it showed.

I will never forget standing at third base, in my coaches box, rocking back and forth waiting for something to happen. And it did. My son got a lead off double. Then right behind him Showtime blasted a home run to the fence. He absolutely crushed the ball and with the speed of those two kids there was no way anyone was going to get the ball in before they crossed home plate. Suddenly it was 7-2 and I thought, “here we come”. A couple more hits, some aggressive base running and we were able to scratch out 2 more runs. Suddenly it was 7-4. A much closer game. Finally we were able to bring in our ace. And the battle was on. We held them scoreless, and took the lead. 8-7 the next inning. Then they took it back, 9-8. The last batter in our lineup tied the game with a home run. 9-9. Our defense held in the bottom of the 6th inning to send the game into extra innings. It was a crazy, a minor league second game championship that went into extra innings.
For what ever reason, we came out swinging. We scored 5 runs in the top of the 7th and held the A’s scoreless. I’ll never forget the look on Rocket’s face (my son) when the batter hit the last out of the game, a pop up to first. Everyone rushed in on Sarge but gave him the room to make the catch. I could see that Matt so badly wanted to get to that ball but he believed in his teammate, gave him space and watched anxiously as he caught it cleanly and the game was over. We had done the impossible. We had climbed up from the losers bracket and won a championship. We had believed and we were rewarded for our belief.
Legacy
I have no idea what will happen this season. But I do know that I now carry a believe rock with me where ever I go. It was a gift. A pocket size river rock with the word “Believe” inscribed in gold letters. A special souvenir for a season I’ll never forget. Whenever I get down, whenever I feel like the world has turned against me, I remember those boys and the purity and strength of their belief, and I have faith. Confidence makes all the difference. You just have to believe.
Sometimes winning it all simply means that you kept the faith when life threw you a curve.
Share on Facebook